Researchers at the University of Wisconsin-Madison found that normalising pro-diversity feelings helped decrease racial discrimination
Showing people how their peers feel about diversity in their community can make their actions more inclusive, make members of marginalised groups feel more like they belong, and even help close racial achievement gaps in education, according to a new study.
Markus Brauer, the UW-Madison psychology professor whose lab designed the pro-diversity ideas intervention:
“In any other domain of public health — saving for retirement, sustainability, eating healthy — it’s the key thing to communicate: It’s the right thing to do, your peers do it, and your peers would actually approve of you doing it as well.”
Drawing on strategies that have worked in anti-smoking, safe-sex and energy-saving campaigns, University of Wisconsin-Madison researchers decided to try to change behavior by showing people that positive feelings about diversity are the norm.
Similar experiments run in the UK
In a two-part documentary on Channel 4, “The school that tried to end racism”, a class of 11-12 year old children are educated about race by Dr Nicola Rollock of Goldsmiths, University of London and Prof Rhiannon Turner of Queen’s University Belfast. The format of these discussions includes discussion of unconscious racial bias, discussing what it means to be white, an exodus of feelings the BAME and white students have about their position in society and more. This learning is done in affinity groups, which are separated by race.
These groups created the space for each race of student to reflect on their relationships to their own race, pro-diversity ideas and to the UK itself.
At the beginning of the experiment, all the children were tested for unconscious bias, and the majority registered as being biased toward white people. After a few weeks, the children were testing majority neutral bias.
The UK is known for being generally “colour-blind”, that is, for not engaging with racial education until it is brought up unavoidably. What happens when the research proves that a different approach creates a more functional society?
Black Lives Matter: The need for pro-diversity ideas
It is an effect that’s reflected in attitudes about ongoing protests over Black people killed by police officers. Exposed to larger crowds, more frequent news coverage and the opinions of friends and neighbors, more people have expressed support for Black Lives Matter groups and activities.
Brauer said: “People are heavily influenced by finding out what their peers have done. But in the diversity domain, we haven’t been trying this.”
The researchers, who published their findings in the journal Nature Human Behaviour, conducted extensive focus groups with UW-Madison students.
The way this experiment was conducted
“We asked them — students of color and white students, students of the LGBT+ community: What actually is it that decreases your sense of belonging? What are the kinds of behaviors that hurt your feelings, that make you feel excluded?
“And then please tell us, what are the behaviors that would make you feel welcome?”
The non-white students felt like they were kept at a distance from white students — not included in class groups or projects, not included in activities, not invited to participate in simple interactions.
“When we asked about what decreased their sense of belonging, they didn’t complain so much about racial slurs or explicit forms of discrimination,” says Brauer. “It was the distance, the lack of interest, the lack of caring that affected them.”
Brauer, graduate student Mitchell Campbell, and Sohad Murrar, a former graduate student of Brauer’s who is now a psychology professor at Governors State University in Illinois, used what they learned to choose their messages.
“We used a social marketing approach, where we identify a target audience, we decide what our target behavior is, and then we show people how their peers support that behavior,” Brauer says.
They designed a relatively simple poster, covered in students’ faces and reporting actual survey results — that 93% of students say they “embrace diversity and welcome people from all backgrounds into our UW-Madison community,” and that 84% of them agreed to be pictured on the poster. They also produced a five-minute video, which described the pro-diversity opinions reported by large majorities in other campus surveys and showed real students answering questions about tolerance and inclusion.
In a series of experiments over several years, hundreds of students were exposed passively to the posters in brief encounters in study waiting rooms or hung day after day on the walls of their classrooms. In other experiments, the video was shown to an entire class during their first meeting. Control groups came and went from waiting rooms and classroom with no posters, or watched videos about cranberry production, or other alternatives to the study materials.
Then the researchers surveyed subjects to assess their attitudes about appreciation for diversity, attitudes toward people of color, intergroup anxiety, their peers’ behaviors and other measures.
Result of pro-diversity ideas in this experiment
“When we measured 10 or 12 weeks later, the students who were exposed to the interventions report more positive attitudes towards members of other groups and stronger endorsement of diversity,” Brauer says.
The differences for students from marginalised groups went further.
“The students belonging to marginalised groups tell us that they have an enhanced sense of belonging. They are less anxious in interactions with students from other ethnic groups. They tell us that they’re less and less the target of discrimination,” Brauer says. “They evaluate the classroom climate more positively, and feel that they are treated more respectfully by their classmates.”
The researchers tested the effectiveness of their diversity intervention in a series of UW-Madison courses in which white students have historically received better grades than their non-white peers. In course sections that viewed the 5-minute video during their first meeting — classes including more than 300 students — the privileged and marginalised students’ grades were equal in the end.
“We know the marginalised students experience discrimination; we know their feelings are valid. But we know, too, from the campus climate surveys and our own extensive surveys, that their fellow students report real appreciation for diversity, and tell us that they want to be inclusive,” Brauer says. “They stay socially distant, though, because they worry about putting themselves out there. Our experience is that this intervention is changing those perceptions and experiences, and possibly the behavior, of both groups.”
It may be the first result of its kind for such a long-running study with so many participants, and the researchers are hopeful that future work will help better reveal whether students actually change the way they treat each other.
How to take pro-diversity ideas forward
“Promoting inclusion and dismantling systemic racism is one of the most important issues of our times. And yet, it turns out that many pro-diversity initiatives are not being evaluated,” says Brauer, whose work was supported in part by funding from the office of UW-Madison’s vice provost and chief diversity officer.
“We really need evidence-based practices, but for a long time we’ve had no idea whether the things we do in the diversity domain actually have a beneficial effect. We’re hoping to change that.”