Keith Taylor MEP, Green Party Member from the European Parliament for the South East region, shares with us his thoughts on the importance of protecting the UK’s environment post-Brexit, including air pollution
Laws without enforcement is really just good advice,” Abraham Lincoln is once believed to have said.1 In other words, ‘good advice’ alone is meaningless when it comes from lawmakers who refuse to put it into action.
It’s a truism that has survived the test of time and, as Britain approaches Brexit, one which takes on extra meaning.
Despite the government’s claim that the EU Withdrawal Bill would be the legislative means by which it transferred the full body of EU law on to the UK statute books2 post-Brexit, it, instead, neglects key protections3 offered by EU membership.
Not included in the bill are some of the vital tenets of EU law; the precautionary and polluter pays principles. Together they act as a robust legal backstop against the destruction of our environment.
Based on the recognition that the environment is unowned, the precautionary principle4 forces developers and those who may do it harm, to prove, in law, that their plans will not damage the environment.
The polluter pays principle5 meanwhile, ensures that preventative action should be taken to avert environmental damage and where that fails the cost burden for clearing up pollution falls on those responsible for creating it.
Moreover, there is no provision for an independent watchdog to replace the enforcement powers of European Commission (EC) and European Court of Justice (ECJ) which have the legal might to take the UK government to court should it fail to live up to its responsibilities.
These are powers the EC was forced to exercise when, during May 2018, it announced it was referring Britain to the ECJ for consistently breaching EU legal limits on toxic air.6
Air pollution is a public health crisis linked to the premature deaths of more than 40,000 Brits every year;7 the UK has been in breach of EU air pollution limits for almost a decade.
The EC’s announcement came just days after the Environment Secretary, Michael Gove, unveiled his plans for a so-called post-Brexit ‘environment watchdog’8 that would have no legal enforcement powers.
Less an effective watchdog, critics have pointed out9 the proposed body would see the government to escape the kind of scrutiny and accountability currently ensured by the EC and ECJ.
Despite the overwhelming majority of British citizens, leave and remain voters alike, being clear that they don’t want to see Brexit exploited as a chance to erode vital environmental protections,10 the government has indicated its desire to do just that.
The enforcement agency conceived by Gove would have neither the power to take the government nor corporations to court nor issue fines or sanctions.
Greens, environmental NGOs, conservation charities, the UN, and the British public have been vocal in their criticism of the proposals.11. At the same time, in the House of Lords, the Conservative Government has been defeated by Peers no less than fifteen times on the EU Withdrawal Bill.12
One of the amendments peers passed calls on ministers to give a post-Brexit environment watchdog some real teeth to ensure that “the rights, powers, liabilities, obligations, restrictions, remedies and procedures that contribute to the protection and improvement of the environment” are not reduced.
It was nothing less than a clear rejection of the government’s watchdog proposals – that would inconvenience neither ministers nor big corporations.
For the sake of the health of our environment post- Brexit, it now falls on MPs to ensure that when the EU Withdrawal Bill returns to the House of Commons, they support the Lords’ amendment.
MPs must not be cowed nor intimidated by lobbyists nor the press, they must have the courage to vote in the best interests of the British people, Britain and her environment.
Again, as Abraham Lincoln said13 ‘you cannot escape the responsibility of tomorrow by evading it today.”
1 https://www.nytimes.com/2015/10/13/science/african-conservationgroup- with-unusual-mission-enforcement.html
2 https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/north-east-news/what-euwithdrawal- bill-brexit-13577212
3 https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2017/oct/17/uk-withdrawal- bill-rips-the-heart-out-of-environmental-law-say-campaigners
6 http://www.keithtaylormep.org.uk/2018/05/17/eu-air-pollution-lawsuitexposes- danger-of-uk-plans-for-a-post-brexit-environmental-lapdogsay- greens/
7 https://www.independent.co.uk/environment/pollution-air-cleanwater- vehicles-diesel-car-tax-lancet-report-deaths-fatal-diseasea8009751.html
8 http://www.keithtaylormep.org.uk/2018/05/10/green-brexit-greensslam- goves-environmental-lapdog-proposals/
9 http://www.itv.com/news/2018-05-10/when-is-a-post-brexit-environmental- watchdog-not-a-post-brexit-environmental-watchdog-when-ithasnt- got-any-teeth/
10 https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2016/aug/25/britishwildlife- needs-new-laws-to-protect-it-post-brexit-poll-shows
11 https://www.europeanscientist.com/en/environment/un-urges-ukto- fulfil-promise-of-a-green-brexit/
12 https://leftfootforward.org/2018/05/lords-have-just-inflicted-another– defeat-on-the-government-and-stood-up-for-our-environment/
Keith Taylor MEP
Green Party Member
European Parliament for the South East region
Editor's Recommended Articles
Must Read >> Will Brexit really help or hinder the NHS?
Must Read >> The future of Britain’s border control after Brexit